The American Civil Liberties Union of Florida rejects the administration of drugs that are dangerous or have significant irreversible effect as an alternative to incarceration; However, they are not opposed to the use of antiandrogen in sex offenders in carefully controlled circumstances as an alternative to incarceration. [37] Law professor John Stinneford argued that chemical castration is a cruel and unusual punishment because it controls the minds of sex offenders to render them incapable of sexual desire and subjects them to physical changes caused by the hormones used. [72] the France, the United Kingdom, Poland, Russia, North Macedonia, Belgium and Turkey have legislation allowing chemical castration. [57]: 16 The drug cyproterone acetate is widely used throughout Europe for chemical castration. It is similar to the MPA drug used in America. [13] The law signed by the Republican governor. Kay Ivey on Monday demanded that people convicted of a sex crime against a child under the age of 13 begin chemical castration treatment before their release, according to CNN. You should continue treatment, which consists of medications designed to lower a person`s libido, until a court decides they can stop. Some criminologists argue that the occurrence of a lower relapse rate in male sex offenders receiving chemical castration treatment than in those who do not may be explained by factors other than the biological effects of the drug. One hypothesis is that men who accept the negative effects of hormone treatment in exchange for a shorter prison sentence differ in that they place more importance on not incarcerating than men who prefer to stay in prison longer than face the side effects of chemical castration. These criminologists apparently explain a lower recidivism than an artifact of men who accept chemical castration by being more concerned with concealing evidence of relapse, and that pardoning these offenders poses a risk of releasing criminals who commit as many new crimes as others, but are better at hiding them.
These criminologists also argue that police investigators who treat castrated men as less repeat offenders than uncastrated men can cause investigative bias and self-fulfilling prophecies, and that men who sell some of their prescribed drugs on the black market for drugs receive hidden income that improves their ability to afford measures to conceal relapses that men without such prescriptions are not. not available. [23] [24] [25] The reasons they gave for this opinion were that MPAs had not yet been classified as safe and reliable (they still are not!), and also because there were problems in obtaining informed consent in these circumstances. Our opinion has not changed since then. The value of chemical castration remains controversial, as it often does not make the aggressor weak or libidoless. We have had a lot of controversy over the years about the unconstitutional restrictions on Michigan`s sex offender registry. But the only thing we don`t have to settle for is the controversy surrounding chemical (or surgical) castration! In fact, the Michigan Court of Appeals ruled in 1984 that ordering chemical castration as a condition of probation was illegal. In response to national outrage over pakistan`s recent surge in rape cases against women and children, lawmakers on Wednesday passed a new anti-rape law to speed up trials and allow for chemical castration of convicted offenders.
In October and November 2013, the North Macedonian authorities worked on the development of a legal framework and standard procedure for the implementation of chemical castration to be used for convicted child molesters. Castration should be voluntary and mandatory for child molesters who repeat the crime. [60] Under the state`s chemical castration law, chemical treatment is not required, but a judge could impose treatment based on the number of crimes or the severity of a crime. Ukraine: In July 2019, the country`s parliament agreed to chemically castrate rapists, even though the state must use force against convicts. The first use of chemical castration took place in 1944, when diethylstilbestrol was used with the aim of reducing testosterone in men. [13] The antipsychotic benperidol has sometimes been used to decrease sexual urges in people who have shown inappropriate sexual behavior, and as administered by depot injection, although benperidol does not affect testosterone and is therefore not a castrating agent.